Archive for February 2013
Christopher Schwarz Workbench ReviewWednesday 20th February 2013
“Two centuries of workbench wisdom in one book”
That’s the bold claim made by Christopher Schwarz former editor of Popular Woodworking magazine about his first book “Workbenches from Design & Theory to Construction & Use”.
- Betterway Books
I purchased the book through Waterstones by visiting a high street shop and ordering a copy for in store collection. I was pleased with the service and I was able to collect the book within a couple of days.
This is the first contemporary Joinery & Cabinet making reference book I have purchased or read. Clearly this book has been produced with the North American woodworker in mind. All dimensions are in imperial and many of the timbers stated as cheap and easy to obtain are in fact, outside of the US, more expensive and only available from specialist suppliers. That said, there is a lot the British or European reader can gain from reading this book as the author focuses heavily on the “English” and “French” style of bench.
The book begins by discussing what the author thinks are the failings of many commercially available and custom-built benches and the challenges encountered when using them. The next section moves on to discuss the types of wood used in the construction, the type of accessories and the various merits of each. The noose then tightens and we move on to why the author selected the “English” and “French” style workbenches. There is then a detailed method showing the construction of each type of bench with plenty of photos, notes, cutting lists and drawings. Finally we have a section on the care and maintenance of your bench once you have made it.
The flow and detail given within each section is logical and well researched and the book flows nicely from what feels a gentle introduction about workbenches leading ultimately to a conclusion where you can imagine yourself stood at the bench you chose to make. I found the writing style relaxed, accessible and coherent. I felt I was discussing workbenches with someone who was keen to share what they had learned and was enthusiastic. My favourite section is “Matching Features to Functions” chapter. The author reviews (using his real experiences) the various merits of various appliances such as the quick release vice, planning stops and bench dogs. The best bit about this section is the context-based comparisons. At no stage do I feel I am being sold to, I simply get a review of what works best for each task weather it be random-orbit sanding or face planning narrow boards. Of course there will be some bias here as these approaches suit the author, however he does provide various options so you don’t feel pushed into any particular area.
The weakest area is probably the timber selection but only if you are reading the book from outside the US. For the European reader I would suggest that European Redwood would be the best timber to use in place of the authors preferred Southern Yellow Pine. It’s also a book that you are unlikely to find on the shelf in the UK. You will most likely need to order a copy and have it sent mail order or call into your bookshop and order a copy.
I have sensed some hostility from some people on forums and blog posts that the benches within this book are an elitist type of workbench from the past. Many people state they can create wonderful work from simple benches constructed from basic materials. I can see their point. I would not use either the “English” or “French” bench in our joinery workshop as we require large benches for assembly and we do a lot of power tool work. However if I was a cabinet maker or working on smaller items of joinery I am sure both bench designs would be an asset, making nearly all tasks easier than using a cheap workbench or a basic one you make. So much so I plan to make my own version of the “French” bench shown in this book. When I do so (with a few revisions to suit the UK) I know I will be well informed thanks to this wonderful book
5 Facts About PineTuesday 5th February 2013
Ok so that’s a really bad title to start. However most people in UK call this timber pine or even more generically softwood! The timber I am talking about is European Redwood. This is what most timber trims such as skirting and architraves, structural timbers and price sensitive joinery is made from. It’s a real jack-of-all-trades timber but be really careful where you use it. We have experienced higher levels of moisture movement and durability issues so proceed with caution……
1 - Weight. European Redwood is a medium to lightweight material weighing in at around 510kgm3. This makes it easy to handle but it still retains strength. For structural uses it can be purchased stress graded to C16 or C24.
2 - Durability. TRADA rate it as class 3 Moderately Durable. In my experience you should not be using this timber in any situations where it is liable to be exposed to the elements. Moderately Durable is misleading and unless treated with preservatives expect a short service life when used in external applications. Structural or construction timbers are often already treated and appear green.
3 - Certified: As this is a European product certification is not normally a problem. It is most often PEFC certified although there are some FSC certified suppliers out there too. Always work with certified timber when you can. Ask your supplier for their chain of custody number to ensure the timber is legally harvested.
4 - Grades: The main grade we use in joinery is Un-Sorted. This is the cleanest grade although many thicker boards still have many knots and defects. Purchasing the “Green Split & Centre Free” version can help remove some of the defects although the sizes in this grade are limited. A Fifth grade is available too. This is what most skirting, architraves and PSE sections are made from. For structural uses it can be purchased in a carcase, C16 or C24 grade.
5 - Mostly Inert: Unlike some timbers European Redwood is not aggressive on fixings. However when used in external applications it is still best to use quality brass or stainless steel fixings. The higher moisture levels experienced outside act as a catalyst and greatly increases the speed of corrosion. However if you are using it untreated in exposed conditions the wood could well rot out before the fixings fail.